Showing posts with label rape apologists. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rape apologists. Show all posts

When is non-consensual sex rape?

>> Tuesday, December 01, 2009

One of the keys to interpreting reactions to the arrest of Roman Polanski is understanding that, culturally speaking, a lot of sexual assaults aren't considered crimes by the men or boys who commit them, and to a lesser extent by the women and girls who are assaulted. Consider this letter to a nationally syndicated advice columnist, and especially the columnist's response.

The writer is confused about whether she was raped, because even though she told a man "many times" that she didn't want to have sex with him, and he went ahead and had sex with her anyway, she wasn't "kicking and fighting him off." In the formal legal sense, the facts as described are unambiguous. Practically, of course, things are a lot more complicated, as the columnist's response reveals.

The columnist seems to be drawing a distinction between rape and "sex that shouldn't happen," with the latter category including sexual assaults between acquaintences when one or both parties are intoxicated. How else are we to understand her otherwise bizarre advice that the raped woman talk to the man who raped her "in order to determine what happened?" The woman's letter indicates no uncertainty at all about the fact that she was forced to have sex against her will despite making it very clear that she didn't want to have sex. She just wants to know if this constitutes rape.

The answer, again culturally rather than formally legally speaking, is that this type of rape isn't "really" rape, because the victim is to blame for putting herself in a compromised situation, i.e., being intoxicated in the presence of a man while having a vagina (the second factor was apparently supefluous in the case of the versatile Mr. Polanski).

These kinds of factors are what makes Polanski's sodomizing of a 13-year-old girl something Anne Applebaum etc. consider a "far from straightforward" situation. It would be nice to think this is a generational thing, and that young people today are getting a clear message that rape is rape, but given both columns of this sort and the response to Polanski's arrest the evidence seems mixed.

UPDATE [by SL]: See also Amanda Hess.

Read more...

Self-Parody is Too Mild a Term

>> Friday, November 27, 2009

Shorter Verbatim Bernard Henri-Levy: "I am mostly thinking about him: Roman Polanski, who I don't know, but whose fate has moved me so much. Nothing will repair the days he has spent in prison. Nothing will erase the immense, unbelievable injustice he has been subjected to."

I suppose it should go without saying that this alleged Major Intellectual cannot be bothered to advance an argument defending the proposition that apprehending someone who raped a 13-year-old and then fled the jurisdiction to evade his punishment constitutes an "immense, unbelievable injustice." (This kind of rhetoric isn't just silly, it's insulting to actual victims of immense injustices. At this rate, BHL would need about 70 adjectives to describe the Cameron Todd Willingham case.) To the extent that one can infer an argument from the surrounding text, the mentions of his wife and family seem to imply a retread of Robert Harris's apparent argument that if you have a spouse and kids you should get one retrospective child rape for free. I once again take this to be self-refuting...

Read more...

Misogynist Crank of the Day

>> Friday, October 30, 2009


"A. She Was A Who-were."

I'm surprised Farley -- whose contempt for the man of letters in question might exceed my own -- didn't beat me to this. But via Edroso, academy of the overrated charter member Gore Vidal shares some of his legendary wit on the subject of child rape:

In September, director Roman Polanski was arrested in Switzerland for leaving the U.S. in 1978 before being sentenced to prison for raping a 13-year-old girl at Jack Nicholson’s house in Hollywood. During the time of the original incident, you were working in the industry, and you and Polanski had a common friend in theater critic and producer Kenneth Tynan. So what’s your take on Polanski, this many years later?

I really don’t give a fuck. Look, am I going to sit and weep every time a young hooker feels as though she’s been taken advantage of?

I’ve certainly never heard that take on the story before.

First, I was in the middle of all that. Back then, we all were. Everybody knew everybody else. There was a totally different story at the time that doesn’t resemble anything that we’re now being told.

What do you mean?

The media can’t get anything straight. Plus, there’s usually an anti-Semitic and anti-fag thing going on with the press – lots of crazy things. The idea that this girl was in her communion dress, a little angel all in white, being raped by this awful Jew, Polacko – that’s what people were calling him – well, the story is totally different now from what it was then.

I can't actually say I'm surprised to hear these sentiments expressed by this prominent "leftist" rather than by a reactionary Alberta judge, but wow. (Trying to pretend that poor Roman was unfairly persecuted for raping a 13-year-old because of homophobia, though, might embarrass even Anne Applebaum.)

Read more...

Blame it on the 70s

>> Saturday, October 10, 2009

This NYT story argues that the American legal system and the culture in general have become far less lenient toward adults having sex with minors since the wild and crazy 1970s. While doing so it softpedals Roman Polanski's crimes, waiting until the 13th graph to mention that the girl he raped testified the rape was forcible, and failing to mention at all that Polanski now faces prison time for fleeing from justice for 30 years, in addition to the crime to which he pleaded guilty.

Worse yet, it frames Polanski's offenses by comparing them to the fictional romance in Woody Allen's film Manhattan, which involved a consensual relationship between a nearly 18-year-old character and Allen's middle aged alter ego. Whatever legal and moral objections might be raised to such a relationship (and they would be considerable if, for example, the Allen character was in a position of trust or authority in regard to the Mariel Hemingway character -- I saw the film 30 years ago and don't remember if this was the case), it nevertheless involves a radically different situation than that in Polanski's real-life rape drama.

The story also contains this almost unbelievably fatuous quote from Polanski's probation report:

Possibly not since Renaissance Italy has there been such a gathering of creative minds in one locale as there has been in Los Angeles County during the past half century. While enriching the community with their presence, they have brought with them the manners and mores of their native lands which in rare instances have been at variance with those of their adoptive land.


In this context it might be worth mentioning that the late 70s did feature high profile films such as Taxi Driver and Pretty Baby, in which 13 and 12 year old girl characters starred as glamorized and disturbingly sexualized siren/prostitutes (Indeed the sexualization of Brooke Shields in general was a creepy motif of the times). But life doesn't get to imitate art without criminal consequences, even in Hollywood.

Read more...

Proudly Joining Woody Allen

>> Monday, October 05, 2009

Guy whose primary work in film involved casting soft-porn flicks calls rape of 13-year-old "a little thing" in rising to the defense of Roman Polanski. Further commentary is presumably rendered superfluous.

Read more...

Anne Applebaum, You've Got To Be Putting Me On

>> Thursday, October 01, 2009

In today's edition, Anne Applebaum attempts to further explain the many complexities that make it "outrageous" that someone who raped a 13-year-old and fled the authorities after pleading guilty was arrested. Apparently, the slut had it coming because her mother permitted her to be alone in the same room with Polanski:


What apalled [sic] me about that story was the mother’s reaction, which should have been “I am coming to get you right now.” There is more than one adult who bears responsibility here, which is part of what makes the story so far from straightforward.


First of all, I am (to put it mildly) skeptical of the idea that any mother who doesn't treat anyone who may interact with her daughter -- including in a professional setting! -- as a child molester is irresponsible. This is Grade A, or "Tim McCarver" level, second-guessing. But even if we assume that the victim's mother should have had the wisdom that Applebaum so easily acquired decades after the fact knowing what happened, it should be obvious that from Polanski's perspective this doesn't provide the slightest mitigation or "complexity" whatsoever. Whether or not her mother acted wisely, the choice to drug and rape an adolescent* was Polanski's alone, and he alone shares the moral and legal responsibility. It's frankly amazing that it's necessary to explain this to anyone, let alone a well-compensated national pundit.

And then, there's this:

Yes, there is “evidence” that Polanski did not know the girls age – or that he was told but did not believe it: He has told people since that, anyway. Pictures of her from the time show a girl who could be anywhere from 12-25.

Given this standard -- in which even actually being informed of a victim's age doesn't constitute evidence -- I don't see any reason to keep statutory rape laws on the books at all. But it's worse: this is the young woman that Applebaum says could be 25. I don't think further elaboration is necessary.

I'm not even sure what to say about someone who continues to invent new erroneous "facts" and transparently specious arguments to defend someone who rapes a 13 year-old, but I think Brad DeLong's argument that "there is grave moral fault attached to everybody who pays the Washington Post company a cent for any purpose whatsoever" is a good start.

*Applebaum considers this characterization erroneous, but needless to say doesn't explain which isn't true. Since both elements were admitted by Polanski in his plea agreement, I'm sticking with them...

Read more...

QOTD

Greenwald, on Fred Hiatt criticizing "French" and "Hollywood" defenses of Polanski while ignoring the defenses of Polanski on his own op-ed page:

But the last thing that ought to be surprising is to find defenses of morally depraved acts on the Op-Ed page of the Post; that is, after all, its essence.

Notably, Cohen's opposition to Polanski's punishment ("it’s alright with me if Roman Polanski is freed") matches almost verbatim his similar defense of Casper Weinberger ("Cap, my Safeway buddy, walks, and that’s all right with me"). That, in turn, is entirely consistent with Cohen's outrage over Lewis Libby's prosecution for obstruction of justice ("As with sex or real estate, it is often best to keep the lights off") and his demand that Bush torturers and war criminals be similarly protected from consequences. The opposition to Polanski's arrest by these Post columnists is, in one sense, merely a natural extension of their general view that criminal prosecution and prison is for the dirty masses but not for elites like themselves.

[...]

For every brutal, lawless and amoral act, there is a defense of it to be found on the Washington Post Op-Ed page.


That pretty much nails it.

Read more...

Further thoughts from Anne Applebaum: The slut was asking for it

>> Wednesday, September 30, 2009

Incredibly, Applebaum's followup to her original contribution on the Polanski rape is even more clueless and offensive than the original:

Of course, there were some very legitimate disagreements, including two excellent ones from my colleagues Gene Robinson and Richard Cohen, and I take some of their points. But to them, and to all who imagine that the original incident at the heart of this story was a straightforward and simple criminal case, I recommend reading the transcript of the victim's testimony (here in two parts) -- including her descriptions of the telephone conversation she had with her mother from Polanski's house, asking permission to be photographed in Jack Nicholson's jacuzzi --and not just the salacious bits.


Here's the relevant part of the transcript:

Q. What happened out there after he indicated he wished to take pictures of you in the jacuzzi?

A. We went inside and called my mother.

Q. When you say “we called,” did you call or did Mr. Polanski call?

A. He told me to and I talked and then he talked and then I talked again.

Q. What did you tell your mother?

A. She goes, “Are you all right?

I went, “Uh-huh.”

And she says, “Do you want me to come pick you up?”

And I went, “No.”

And he said that we’d be home kind of late because it had already gotten dark out.

Q. When you said “he said,” did he tell you or did you hear him tell your mother on the phone?

A. He told my mother.

Q, Did he tell your mother any other things?

A. Not that I was listening to.

Q. After talking to your mother on the telephone, what happened?

A. We went out and I got in the jacuzzi.

Applebaum can't even read 20 lines of a trial transcript accurately (the victim never asked her mother for permission to be photographed in the jacuzzi). But that idiocy pales to insignificance in comparison to the moral blindness involved in suggesting, as Applebaum clearly does, that if the 13-year-old victime had in fact asked her mother's permission to be photographed in a jacuzzi by a 44-year-old man that would somehow transform the man's subsequent drugging and raping of the girl into something other than a "simple and straightforward criminal case."

Applebaum's first post on this subject might have been ever so slightly excused by the possibility that she simply hadn't thought through exactly what she was defending. This has no such excuse.

Read more...

About This Blog

  © Blogger template Simple n' Sweet by Ourblogtemplates.com 2009

Back to TOP