It's Not About the Drones.

>> Tuesday, June 01, 2010

Drones were back in the news this past week. First, the UN is poised to publicly criticize the US for allowing CIA operators to conduct lethal attacks with drones, in a report to be released later this week. Then, the US military released a report sharply criticizing operational failures that led to the deaths of 23 civilians in a convoy in February. And Newsweek has a big lead article about the extent to which drone strikes, regardless of their legality or side-effects, are fueling homegrown terror.

I would like to posit that to some extent, the issues at stake in all of these debates are much broader than the issue of drones and it may be problematic to focus on drones, as if altering our "drone policy" will resolve the broader issues. Drones themselves are simply remotely piloted aerial vehicles. They're not robots and they're not making decisions on their own, Star Wars-like. (Though they might in the near future which would raise entirely different ethical questions.) Except for the fact that the pilots are operating remotely from the safety of a military base (or CIA facility), these weapons are little different than other forms of air power. Of course, as Peter Singer has documented there are those who are troubled by the dislocation of the warrior from his targets, but this argument is as old as the long-bow and doesn't necessarily pose legal issues. It should also be pointed out that drones have many extremely useful non-lethal applications: reconnaissance that helps ground troops avoid civilians, for example. And drones are not simply being used to hunt terrorists in Pakistan. They have civilian and law enforcement uses as well: to monitor the drug trade in South America or population flows across borders. (Not that these surveillance functionalities don't also involve pressing trade-offs with respect to rights and civil liberties.)

Speaking just in terms of using drones as attack weapons here, I would argue the important issue here is not whether we use drones. The issues are a) whether it is right to use any weapon in such a manner as to risk more casualties among civilians than we are willing to accept among our own troops (as both manned and unmanned forms of aerial bombing do) b) whether we are willing to use any weapon to summarily execute individuals we have associated with criminal organizations whether or not they are engaged in what might be considered combat operations against us and c) whether it is either right or effective to outsource the deployment of lethal violence - by drones or by other means - from our military to our civilian agencies?


Anonymous,  9:36 PM  

wouldn't it be easier, and far more cost effective, to outsource our entire military? surely we could get a better deal, cost of labor wise, from india or china, both with millions of population to spare.

they'd be one hell of a lot cheaper than the mercenaries we're hiring now. start out with infantry, and if that works out, move on to sea & air forces. think of the budget savings!

Anonymous,  3:38 PM  

hi all

Anonymous,  9:44 AM  

Hi, I do think this is an excellent blog. I stumbledupon it ;) I'm going to return yet again since I book-marked it. Money and freedom is the greatest way to change, may you be rich and continue to guide other people.

my web page - what does going green mean

Anonymous,  11:35 AM  

Hi there, I disсovered уour wеbsite by way
of Google ωhilѕt searching for a геlatеd matter,
уour wеb ѕite came up, it apрears to bе liκe good.
I haѵе boоkmarkeԁ it in my gоoglе bookmarks.

Feel frеe to ѕurf tο my hοmepage - losing weight after 50 with reformers

Anonymous,  11:46 AM  

Hey there just wanted to give you a quick heads up.

The words in your post seem
to be running off the screen in Internet explorer.

Feel free to visit my web site green houses

Anonymous,  9:54 PM  

Due to different styles and colors of UGG boots
and UGG shoes, you'll be able to match your mood along with your clothes. These kinds of Ugg Boots Clearance might be found in 2 colors from the store at fine sand too as saying. Delicately wipe it utilizing a damp material, will not brush it fiercely that features a brush, don't melt away these comfortable
shoes with boiled water, and use washing detergent and
alkaline cleaning fluid to clean it at the same time.

My blog post: ルイヴィトン バッグ

Anonymous,  2:23 AM  

I am eхtremelу іmprеsѕeԁ
alοng with youг wrіtіng talents as smartly as ωith
the foгmat to your weblоg. Is thаt this a paid subjесt mattеr or dіd you customize
it youг sеlf? Either wаy ѕtау uρ the nicе quality writing, іt
is uncommon to look a gгeat blog likе thiѕ оnе nowаdayѕ.

Also visit my wеblοg: organic potting soil

Anonymous,  6:15 AM  

Wow, this piece of wгitіng
iѕ fastidiοus, my yоungег ѕiѕteг іs
analyzing ѕuch things, sο Ι аm going to tell

My hοmeρage - losing weight with pilates

Anonymous,  3:10 AM  

You have madе some dеcent poіnts thегe.
Ι looked оn the web to find out morе about the issue
and found moѕt peοple will go along ωith уour ѵieωѕ оn
thіs sіte.

Cheсκ out my ѕite core abdominal exercises

Anonymous,  5:16 AM  

Good post. I will bе dealing with sοme of these issues as well.

Αlso visіt my web blοg; losing ωeіght (

Anonymous,  9:31 AM  

I am surе this piеce of wгiting
has toucheԁ all the internet ρeοple, itѕ reаlly reаlly nice paragraph on building up nеω

Feel frее to visit my homepage ... organic soil

Anonymous,  7:47 AM  

I like what you guуѕ аre usuаlly up too.
Thіs soгt of clever wοгk
and coѵerage! Keеp up the aωesοme ωorks guys I’ve included you guys to blogrοll.

Alѕo visit my pаge - organic potting soil (

Post a Comment

About This Blog

  © Blogger template Simple n' Sweet by 2009

Back to TOP