Showing posts with label crime and punishment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crime and punishment. Show all posts

Dumond This Isn't

>> Sunday, November 29, 2009

Given Huckabee's gruesome history on related matters, it's tempting to say that he deserves any demagoguery he's on the receiving end of because of this. But it would be wrong. As Matt says, on its face there's nothing unreasonable about granting clemency to a someone given 60 years for burglaries committed when he was 17. Evidently, if you grant parole and clemency (or, for that matter, give out finite sentences) to significant numbers of people some percentage will commit more crimes, but individual cases can't in themselves justify more draconian policies, and also don't mean that Huckabee's judgment at the time was wrong. Putting pressure on the the parole board to release a rapist because some wingers developed some quarter-witted Clinton conspiracy theories, on the other hand...

I also wonder if this might affect Kennedy's vote on the juvenille sentencing cases the court is considering.

Read more...

"Wilding"

>> Friday, November 27, 2009

Dave linked to this outburst below. It's worth noting that when American Thinker Robin from Berkeley describes what she calls the "wilding of Sarah Palin," she fails to mention that the original "wilding" -- the infamous rape of the Central Park jogger in 1989, resulted in the wrongful convictions of six teenage boys, who collectively ended up spending several decades in prison for a crime they didn't commit.

Read more...

Crime and punishment

>> Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Several commentators in the Polanski thread are apparently taking the view that if a particular exercise of criminal punishment is unlikely to deter crime or rehabilitate the offender, then punishing the offender is pointless at best if not actually barbaric.

Leaving aside the question of whether or not punishing Polanski would deter anyone from committing rape in general or child rape in particular, I find it odd that some people so easily dismiss the idea that Polanski should be punished because he deserves to be punished. One doesn't have to be a strict Kantian to accept the idea that a person who commits a henious crime should be punished irrespective of whether the punishment specifically deters the offender, or generally deters others from committing similar acts.

For example, I imagine hardly anyone would accept the idea that if Polanski had murdered his victim it would be wrong to punish him unless one could show the punishment was likely to deter murder.

All of which is to say that arguments about how there's no "point" in punishing Polanski now are only plausible to the extent that it's accepted that what Polanski did wasn't a particularly serious crime.

Read more...

About This Blog

  © Blogger template Simple n' Sweet by Ourblogtemplates.com 2009

Back to TOP